Google Pixel Watch 3 vs Pixel Watch: Should you upgrade?

Google’s latest smartwatch represents the brand’s third generation since entering the wearables landscape. The Pixel Watch 3 introduces significant hardware and software improvements, including multiple size options. Find out how the new watch ranks against the OG model in this Pixel Watch 3 vs Pixel Watch comparison.

Google has retained an attractive and unique minimalist look to its wearables from the original launch through to the current model. Both the first and third generations feature domed Gorilla Glass displays, circular cases, a rotating bezel, and integrated watch bands. They also each boast 5ATM water resistance and a package of sensors on the backside.

This year, however, the Pixel Watch 3 includes not just one 41mm case size but a second 45mm one as well. This means a larger option for those with bigger wrists (or just those who prefer a larger device). Across both sizes, upgrades also include new AMOLED-LTPO displays that are bigger and brighter than those of the past, with a variable refresh rate of 60hz. The new models even feature shrunken bezels to further stretch screen real estate. In hand, the Pixel Watch 3 is an attractive upgrade.

The Pixel Watch 3 is also available in slightly different colorways than the original model and adds a gorgeous Hazel aluminum case to the mix. The specs table above shows a complete breakdown of each model’s colorways in comparison to what shoppers will find from the original lineup. However, since bands are interchangeable and can be replaced, the case colors are the most significant factor to consider.

Feature-wise, the newest model brings a lot to the table. Not only does it land with a more powerful processor, improved dual-chip architecture, and a more feature-packed and power-efficient Wear OS, it even boasts evolved integration with other Google and Pixel products and services. It also adds features that leverage AI. Users can access tools like phone call screening and hold, Pixel phone and car unlock, Find My Phone, and Google TV remote controls, as well as Nest live streams, updated Pixel phone camera controls, and a new Recorder app.

For health and fitness tracking, the Pixel Watch 3 improves heart rate accuracy and sleep tracking and finally adds automatic bedtime mode to detect when you fall asleep to reduce battery burn. The device also introduces a slew of upgrades for runners, including real-time guidance during workouts, running efficiency metrics, media controls integrated into your workout screen, a new on-device workout builder, and PR tracking. In the Fitbit app, runners will also find a new running dashboard with additional analysis.

Google also launched an upgraded Daily Readiness Score that is now accessible to all users (not just Premium members), as well as Cardio Load for measuring your exertion and Target Load for customized activity goal setting based on what your body actually needs. A new Morning Brief feature supplies a synopsis of key metrics as well as details about the upcoming day. These tools represent a growing trend toward holistic wellness tracking, and they help users balance both activity and recovery. Fitbit Premium users can access even more features, including daily run recommendations and additional workout-related content.

Finally, both Pixel Watch 3 models offer a much better experience in terms of battery life. To be fair, the Pixel Watch 2 refined this aspect of the first generation last year with better specs and fast charging capabilities. The newest model builds on this trajectory with larger battery cells, even more efficiency, and the introduction of battery saver mode to provide up to 36 hours of battery between charges.

Freshly launched, the Google Pixel Watch 3 runs shoppers a pretty penny. The lineup starts at $349 for a 41mm model and $399 for the 45mm option. Adding LTE connectivity to either size adds $100 more to the price tag. The devices are available now for preorder and will officially hit shelves on September 10, 2024.

The 41mm Pixel Watch originally launched at $349 as well, though an LTE model only cost shoppers an extra $50. Now that the device has been outdone twice over, it can often be found at a greatly reduced price. However, it can also be tricky to find one available for purchase. The best bet is to check third-party retailers like Amazon.

We’ve seen significant improvements within the Pixel Watch line, and the newest generation is a much more powerful device than the original model. It also comes in two case sizes, so you can finally opt for a larger device if the 41mm feels too dainty. Even if you choose the smaller model Pixel Watch 3, it still boasts a larger, brighter display without jeopardizing the established elegant, minimalist aesthetic. In other words, the new generation is a much better device.

Internally, the Pixel Watch 3 also runs Wear OS 5 out of the box, and the latest software packs a ton of user experience upgrades, including powerful integration with other Google and Pixel products and services. It also boasts better battery and charging specs, both of which were a major shortcoming of the original model. Meanwhile, athletes in particular, can benefit from the advanced health and training tools added to the latest devices.

If the budget is tight, it might be worth checking out the Pixel Watch 2, which has seen a substantial price drop since the 3’s arrival. The last generation refined a few of the first generation’s quirks for an overall better user experience.