A congressional hearing devolved into an angry confrontation between a senator and a witness on Tuesday after Republican Sen. Markwayne Mullin of Oklahoma challenged Sean O’Brien, the president of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, to “stand your butt up” and settle longstanding differences right there in the room.
Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, the chair of the Senate panel that was holding the hearing, yelled at Mullin to sit down after he challenged O’Brien to a fight.
Mullin had stood up from his seat at the dais and appeared to start taking his ring off.
“This is the time, this is the place,” Mullin told O’Brien after reading a series of critical social media posts O’Brien had sent about him in the past. “If you want to run your mouth, we can be two consenting adults. We can finish it here.”
The two men never came face to face in the hearing room.
But they hurled insults at each other for around six minutes as Sanders repeatedly banged his gavel and tried to cut them off.
‘You are a United States senator!’
Sanders, a longtime union ally, pleaded with them to focus on the economic issues that were the focus of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee hearing, which Sanders was holding to review how unions help working families.
“You are a United States senator!” Sanders yelled at Mullin at one point.
Mullin, a frequent critic of union leadership, has sparred before with the union head. Earlier this year, O’Brien posted repeatedly about Mullin on X, formerly known as Twitter, calling him a “moron” and “full of s–t.” This followed a separate hearing where Mullin criticized O’Brien for what he said were intimidation tactics.
In another social media post, which Mullin read aloud at Tuesday’s hearing, O’Brien appeared to challenge Mullin to a fight. “You know where to find me. Anyplace, Anytime cowboy,” O’Brien had posted.
The exchange escalated from there, with Mullin telling O’Brien that “this is the place” and asking if he wanted to do it right now. “I’d love to do it right now,” O’Brien said. Mullin replied: “Well, stand your butt up then.”
“You stand your butt up,” O’Brien shot back.
When Mullin got up from his seat, appearing ready for a fight, Sanders yelled at him to sit down, banged his gavel several times and told both of them to stop talking.
“This is a hearing, and God knows the American people have enough contempt for Congress, let’s not make it worse,” Sanders said.
As Mullin persisted, O’Brien retorted: “You challenged me to a cage match, acting like a 12-year-old schoolyard bully.”
The two traded angry insults for several more minutes — each called the other a “thug” — with Mullin at one point suggesting they fight for charity at an event next spring, repeating an offer he made earlier this year on social media.
O’Brien declined, instead suggesting they meet for coffee and work out their differences.
Mullin accepted, but the two kept shouting at each other until the next senator, Democratic Sen. Maggie Hassan of New Hampshire, started her questioning by talking over them.
Exchange called ‘absurd’
After the hearing, Sanders called the exchange “absurd.”
“We were there to be talking about, and did talk about, the crisis facing working families in this country, the growing gap between the very rich and everybody else and the role that unions are playing in improving the standard of living of the American people,” Sanders said.
“We’re not there to talk about cage fighting.”
Asked later about the skirmish, Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell demurred.
“It’s very difficult to control the behaviour of everybody who is in the building,” McConnell said. “I don’t view that as my responsibility.”
Republican Sen. Kevin Cramer of North Dakota said references were made to the back-and-forth in a GOP conference meeting after the hearing.
But he said it shouldn’t be taken too seriously.
“It’s a dynamic place,” Cramer said of the Senate. “We don’t wear the white wigs anymore.”